Even though it sounds silly, pink would be the best color. Not a barbie pink, but a subtle light pink. Just dust it lightly over your cheeks and spread up past cheekbones. Nothing dramatic. I know what you mean though, I am fair skinned, and red tones in my hair. That’s what I use.
For your skin tone I would suggest a rosy pink. Nars has a blush called orgasm and it works really well. Check it out.
Answer my question please
NARS blush in Orgasm……it’s a light pink w/ gold undertones…very good color for your skin color.
A peachy pink would look ace!
What color do your cheeks turn when you’ve gone on a jog? Buy that color. Make sure the color is buildable, meaning you can start light, then increase if you want a more flushed look.
I would suggest a very pale pink, but make sure it is a pink not a peach because peach colors tend to look like bronze or orange tones. Pink is always a good choice for both times of the year but since you are fair skinned with red hair, I would suggest using the bronze in the summertime and the pink in the winter time. Here are a few favorite pink blushes of mine:
Wet N Wild in Naive or HeatherSilk
Covergirl in Natural Rose, Rose Silk or Classic Pink
Sephora in Peche Tendre 4, Rose Rebelle 1
NYC in Central park Pink
Enjoy! and I hope I have helped!